Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts

Friday, November 5, 2010

november 3rd 2010 - thank you israel

“I need to see Jakeline” i demanded firmly as i looked at my cell phone watch at 8:59am .  My appointment with Jakeline was at 9am.  I had left the house at 6:25 am from Ramallah to get to Jerusalem to meet with her.  After I lost my passport the second week of September, I’ve had no visa or documentation that makes my stay here legitimate in any way, forget about the West Bank, in Israel or in this area in general.  Using my second passport, I was at least able to prove that I’m American, which is the only ID that I have on me that proves my American-ness.  Losing an American passport outside of the States, is a huuuuuuge deal, because it sells for thousands of dollars in the black market.  After waiting for 2 weeks for it to turn up, I went to Jerusalem to the Consulate to order a new passport, and was told that my old passport would be cancelled, and no one would be able to use it.  At the Consulate, the man who was helping me, quietly told me that to get another passport and another visa I can’t have any documentation that says I was in the West Bank.  That morning he told me to go walk 25 minutes uphill to Jaffa Gate, he told me where the police station was, and he told me to get a police report done there, and tell them that I lost my passport that day, that morning.
It’s almost jarring how I can lie now on demand to authority when it’s necessary.  I casually went up to the police station, and during my walk, i thoguht for a second “hmm what should my story be for the police” and that throught twas followed by “meh dont think about it”.  sitting across from the Isreali police, i just made shit up, saying that that morning I was in the old city with some of my friends, I was at the french bookshop (which I passed on my walk to the police station) and i had gotten a book which was the last time I had my wallet, and then when we were sitting down for coffee I realized I didnt have my entire wallet so I dont know where it is, I must have dropped it somewhere in the old city (which is a big place) and i need to report a lost passport because that’s super important.
Doing so got me my police report , and official piece of paper with lots of Hebrew everywhere, which is always a good thing in this part of the world when you have to deal with the IDF.

My new passport came after another 3 weeks.  And then I had to set up a meeting with the Latin Patriarchate in Jerusalem to see if I could get a visa..the visa that I had been waiting the whole summer for in Jordan, the reason why I was stranded in Jordan for a couple of months in the first place, and the visa that i had gotten miraculously at the end of the summer..and the one that I managed to lose.  

So that appoitnment was today.  at 9am. with Jakeline.

The man looked at me for a split second like I was crazy.  “Who’se Jakeline?” he asked.  now it was my turn to look at him blankly. “crap” i thought, i dont even know Jakeline’s last name.  I’ve just been in email correspondence with her for the past year. “i’m from Ramallah and I work for the Latin Patriarchate and I need to see Jakeline.  she works here?” and he goes “ohhh the church is down the street, and then you will take a right and then you will go up the street and the church is at the end of the road”.  Where the hell was I standing?? Turns out I had walked into a hotel with a church name that also happened to have the word “latin’ in it and had walked straight into the lobby of the hotel to ask the receptionist...about Jakeline.  I kind of told the wrong person that I work in the West Bank.  oops.

The reason why I didnt know where the church was, is because I had never been there before.  Though I work for them and though I use their address as my residential address, this was the first time in about a year that I was actually seeing my ‘home’.  

I walked into the church after the walking on winding roads, found Jakeline, and she told me to come back at 12 and told me to stay close to the area by the church, in case the interior ministry people who are the Israeli officials securing my visa, would want to see me in person to verify that everythign was ‘true’ or to see me since I had lost my passport and all of that.  As I handed her my passport, I felt strange thinking “well this is it”.   A month before that my boss had said to me “you need to keep in touch and follow up with Jakeline.  I dont want you to get deported” and that was ringing in my ears.  Would I get deported? Would I be leaving my teaching and my students? I”m not sure, I have no idea.  In a strange way even though I’ve definitely learned more than anythign to let go of any feelings of certainty, one still has a tendency to worry being always in the middle of a mental tug of war, being pulled in one direction that makes you the happiest to the other direction where all of that can be taken away instantaneously.  
I had 2 and a half hours to kill before getting that passport back.
I came back at noon.  She hadn’t called me to tell me that I was to be called in, in person to be questioned or anything, so in my mind, I thought, wait either that’s really good or really bad? it’s a complete rejection or a complete approval? here goes
At 12i went in, and I went up the narrow set of stairs to her office and she was sitting at her desk, a bunch of papers and 2 X 2 passport photos of Catholic nuns of all colors and their applications spraweled all over her desk, probably applying for the same visa i had applied for.
She handed me my passport, and taking up two entire pages was a typed up printed piece of document that said that I am legal in Israel until October 3rd, 2011 with multiple entry, a big “M” stamped on the second page.

She told me that BECAUSE i lost my passport, they had to apply for the visa agian today and then renew it today, so in a weird way BECAUSE i lost my passport, I have an additional 3 months in Palestine, until October 3rd 2011 instead of July 2011.

Mutliple entry.  I can leave and come back without any questions, from country to country, if i want to go to jordan, i can go and come back without worrying that i will be sent back.  A year.  I can move around from city to city within the West Bank.  I dont have to worry about leaving the Israeli borders every 3 months, and stressing if I am coming back or not.  I can be here LEGALLY.  I am LEGAL.  
I still havent processed this, and to many of my friends this may sound like not a big deal.  but I can not begin to tell you HOW BIG OF A DEAL THIS IS.  what i had in my hands was like holding diamonds.  this kind of documentation, this kind of permission, JUST DOESNT HAPPEN.  I didnt know what to do, i was in shock.  So i went out, and because it was noon, church bells were ringing loud and clear and ringing through the entire city and with the visa in my hand i couldnt help but think “JESUS CHRIST!!! ..eff you Israel you messd up so bad! THANK YOU!”.

I dont knwo what to think.  I’m not sure who to express this to, but to be here for a year legally in Palestine is almost unheard of (I’m sure it happens, but very very very veryyyy few in numbers)
this has put a completely new twist on my frame of mind.  Firstly I still can’t let go of my 10 months of lifestyle : constantly and always bieng on pins and needles thinking about the uncertainty of living here, 3 months at a time.  10 months just to do the calculation for you is roughly 300 days lol, which is a long time.  and to suddenly think that wait...i can actually move around from city to city.  i can leave the country and come back.  is ..too much to process it feels like.
This certainly doesnt mean that i HAVE to stay until October, but it gives me option.  To pass up on a 3 month legal stay here doesnt only seem silly but almost stupid.  
Wakling out, without even thinking I looked up to think “God you really DO want me to stay in the Holy Land!” what are the chances? that my passport being lost would result in THIS? Everything happens for a reason.

With a year at hand, I feel like there are countless things I can get my hands into.  First and foremost: research.  I’ve been talking to a lot of people about my teachign expereince here, and me wondering about research regarding conflict zone psychology.  these kids that i deal with, do things and act in ways that will shock you.  and there is absolutely no data or documentation of these behaviors, or causes, or implications of these things.

This was just to update you.  If you know of any department or any professor that needs or requires or wants field work in Palestine, I am here, and would love to connect with academics.  
Until I process more and find more things, this is it for me.  I”m sure i’ll be getting in touch with you to bounc around some ideas.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Safwan










I met him upstairs beaming with a giant smile and embracing me as his friend 2 seconds after finding out what my name was.  The upstairs, a big open space with a two giant doors leading to a small balcony overlooking the garden had a single mattress on the floor,  and Safwan was peeking out a little bit anticipating to see M upon hearing her voice.  I had heard so much about this little 6 year old boy and I was eager to meet him.  He dragged his little body across the room and let himself be scooped by my M into her arms. 

I was eager to meet this boy for many reasons.  One of the main ones being that he was the reason my roommate is in Palestine and will continue to be here.  The second because I heard his story.  Born with Spinal Bifada, paralyzed from the waist down, he was abandoned by his parents, left to die in the hospital.  His disability, half a paralyzed body, a large head, was too much to bear for the then 15 year old mother, and both parents abandoned the newborn.  A group of Catholic nuns (from Mother Teresa’s Missionaries of Charities group) took him in.  And raised him since.

I was astonished to hear his English, fluent and perfect, without a trace of any struggle to express any thoughts or emotion that second language learners often face.  He grew up bilingual at the Sister’s house hearing them speak a communal English (the sisters are all stationed here coming from various countries, with English being their binding language, which turns into a mixture of old English meets formal English meets colonial english) and Safwan picked up their lingo along with his native knowledge of Arabic.

I was astonished by his warmth.  That afternoon, was my first time in a convent, and in an orphanage.  And this place was an orphanage inside of a convent.  The top floor was for outcasted children, who were left to perish before they were taken in by these Sisters. The other kids that I saw were barely moving.  One sat up on the floor staring off into the distance.  The other was sitting in her wheelchair, completely non functional.  Clapping in front them sort of elicited a response but for the most part they were severely disabled, not stimulated by anything at all, they needed to be changed and fed and they lived.  This was also my first exposure to disabled children.  I would be lying if I said I wasn’t nervous and uncomfortable.  Playing with safwan for half an hour made me completely forget that he was a paralyzed child and that half of his body didn’t work.  He was just this vivacious kid excited to watch movies on maggie’s laptop and play catch throwing around a giant ball across the room.
The bottom floor was for women who otherwise have no place in society, some battered so severely that they have lost all mental capabilities, others who are senile due to abuse or age.

I remember thinking how can someone abandon their child? how sad it must be to grow up in an orphanage.  I was corrected on this issue by Maggie saying “thank god Safwan was abandoned! He grew up with 5 mothers! (the sisters) who knows what his parents would have done to him if they had actually taken him, he’d probably have been left to die, or locked up somewhere because they were so ashamed of his existence.  Safwan had two other siblings.  One of whom was fed a bottle of bleach and had to be rushed to the hospital.  The kid miraculously survived.
Once in a while safwan’s dad visits to take safwan around town to beg for money and then after collecting the money for himself, he returns safwan to the Sisters.  Sounds like a movie doesn’t it?

A couple of weeks after I met safwan, he came to Ramallah for 2 weeks for some necessary medical procedures.  During that time, M had created a rotating schedule of friends who would go spend time with safwan at the hospital for several hours during the day and then Maggie would spend her nights at the hospital with him.  I’d play with safwan, and watch him wheeeeeeeeee through the hallway on his wheelchair, talking to every single person on that floor.  Running after him I met some of the most interesting characters, and at that point in time, those were my first interactions with Palestinian Palestinians.  I met a man suffering from bullet wounds from Jenin, and his entire extended family who would sit me down in their room for hours to ask me a variety of questions and then feed me sweets and ask about safwan.  I guess that’s when I really bonded with safwan, spending time with him in the hospital, helping with his homework, or just fooling around with the camera.

You would think occasions like Mother’s day would be a sad day for little safwan, since he is fully aware about what his parents did and how they feel about him, but it actually ends up pretty humorous.  He gets confused why he makes only one mother’s day card, because if there is only one, who amongst the five Sisters, who have all been mothers to him, is supposed to get that one card?

As bright and lovable as safwan is, the truth of the matter is that he has absolutely no future in Palestine.  Disabilities won’t get you far. To have a future of any kind ,he needs to get out.  Knowing this, Maggie’s been on the hunt for a family that would be willing to adopt him.  you’d think that that would be the problem.  But no, there is already a family lined up from Spain who is waiting for Safwan, knowing his background and his life story.  However the problem comes in with his biological parents.  And the community who stirred up this controversy that the Sisters are just simply trying to convert this little boy and that sending him away to Spain would only complete their mission. 

And that “legally” adoption is not a possibility because the State law (what state?) and “Islam” (the same Islam where the Prophet (pbuh) himself was an orphan?) forbids it. 

???? I was so perplexed hearing this.  Where did this come from?? That adoption is illegal in islam? After doing much research and literally obsessing over this and many other issues of Islamic jurisprudence, I still have no answer to why people would intervene in the life of a disabled boy to stop him from having a better life with the dogma of religion.  Somehow handing the boy over to a Christian family would be injustice to islam (according to the townspeople) but ..sending him back to the father (which is something they suddenly decided to instigate and provoke, by literally buying the father off) who has no problem abandoning his child or attempting to kill them would be preserving islam?

Not having Muslim friends around  anymore or not having anyone of the same faith to immerse into Islamic conversation with  (in real life, not virtual cyberspace), situations like this heightens a sense of urgency to figure out how political, social and cultural elements of society can use religion to come up with ridiculous jurisdictions and cover it up in the name of a blanket term “islam”.  Especially when the conversation is happening with a non muslim, and even though I am not directly held accountable, I am still somehow on this other side that “forbids” something so noble.   It sends me on desperate hunt to dig and search for the truth, whatever that may be, hidden under so many many things.

Often times I make sense of things by telling myself that it’s not Islam with the flaws, its Muslims, and the lack of unity and a deeper understanding of faith and the spirit of Islam that gives birth to so much of the complexities within the community.  Of course this issue is not exclusive to islam and muslims, it exists in all groups. The freedom of will to interpretation comes with the burden of too many types of interpretations leaving a dangerous space for manipulation and blind stupidity.  i wish instead of muslims constantly defending islam to outsiders by having a selective scattered cliffnote collection of Quranic verses and hadiths, they’d look inwards to become active and progressive agents of unity and change within the internal community.  Instead of wasting so much time digging up and arguing about the past, I wish people would struggle more with figuring out answers for the present and the future by admitting when and where they are or were wrong. I wish humanity would come before dogma.   


*This adoption question led me on a quest to ask anyone and everyone I know about this, including professors, friends and family members.  I found out speaking with my mother, that nowhere in Islam does it say that adoption is "illegal".  In fact she herself has 2 cousins who have adopted children in Bangladesh, and though its a complicated issue, it certainly is not a forbidden one.                                                                                                                          

Sunday, May 2, 2010

"the good samaritan"

I always knew that the phrase “being a good Samaritan” was something that meant being kind in some way, being a good neighbor/ compadre so to speak.  But did you know that they, the Samaritans,  are an actual group of people who live on top of a hill in the city of Nablus in Palestine? And that there’s only 700 of them left in the world? Some of them live on this hill and some live in a place called Holon, outside Tel Aviv, Israel ( and these are the only 2 spots on earth where they can be found) But they all, all 700 of them, gather together once a year for Passover on top of that mountain, Mount Gerizim, to commemorate a super ancient tradition of Passover, from the days of Prophet Moses, the traditions of which, according to the Samaritans, have been  kept holy and unchanged for 3600 years.

Judaic Passover commemorates ancient Israelites being freed from slavery from the ancient Egyptian pharoahs, and it’s a time when people reflect on the struggles of the ancient Jews. Most images of Passover conjure up quiet time of reflection and.. flatbread.  The Samaritan Passover is quite different.  And quite bloody.


A couple of weeks ago, M, the French teacher Marie, and I  took off to Nablus right after school to go see the Samaritan Passover, a special invitation that I couldn’t really pass up.  It was quite an event and I was shocked to see more photographers and journalists and spectators from around the world attending this event than the actual Samaritans! They didn’t seem to mind, this was not a quiet secretive affair, in fact it was very much the opposite.  We got there around 3:30 pm  and the actual festiviites did not start until the sun set on the sunny clear sky.  Children wore all white, and older men in the community walked around with long robes and a special hat.  Walking inside a gated area, we saw giant pits blazing with fire, and the children adding in logs to light up the pits more, in preparation for the meat festivities that were to come later on.  Straight in front of me was a comical sight, I thought, because there was a set of bleachers set up similar to those that you’d see in a kid’s mini league baseball game.  Except for this one, on either sides, stood armed Israeli soldiers with the Israeli flags flying over them.  The crowds got bigger and bigger, and more and more robed men entered through the gates, and after a while they all took their seats and chanted for a good while.  The highest priest of the community was pretty easy to pick out.  He was an old,  large man that came in with a bright vivacious silky green robe, with a suited man walking in front of him holding the bottom of the priest’s robe up from the gound so that it doesn’t get in the way of the priest walking.  His age and his clothes said it all.  Photographers snapped away and pretty soon we were relocated to a special area, the non Samaritan spectator area, which after an hour got packed like a can of sardines with barely any spot to move. 


Truth be told, I had no idea what I was witnessing.  It was a lot of standing, lot of waiting, lot of being crushed and tiered restless feet, wondering when the stupid sun would set.  Photographers were literally climbing on top of us to get some good shots of Samaritan spiritual leaders sitting in the center area waiting for the feast to begin.  An hour or so before the sun set, a herd of sheep were brought in.

Fastforward 3 hours.  Pure madness and chaos.  The sheep were all slaughtered, herds of people were standing on rooftops, trying to get a glimpse of the Samaritan leaders singing and chanting and praying, and seeing the fresh bloody sheep, being placed on a series of large hooks, hung for everyone to see.  The Samaritans all had a smear of the fresh sheep blood on their foreheads and they went about carrying huge wooden stakes to hang the sheep which would be prepared and cooked in those giant pits and not eaten till midnight. 


The Samaritans reject the Jewish, Christian and Islamic focus on Jerusalem, and instead believe that Mount Gerizim as God’s chosen site.  They boast a continuous lineage from Prophet Moses’ brother and have a complete record of the high priests of their community that stretch across over 130 generations*.

I am continually surprised at the permitted and prohibited lines drawn in and around Palestinian communities by Israeli authority, restricting movement, and perpetually squeezing them into tight spaces.  Though this Mountain is on top of Nablus, there is a checkpoint outside of the Samaritan community that does not allow Palestinians to pass through.   


Sunday, March 21, 2010

"Why Protest Rebuilding a Synagogue"








Recently, along with the clashes, a synagogue in East Jerusalem was re-opened which caused extreme violence in the area.  This is an article that I received over a listserv that I'm on that I feel does a good job of explaining why the reopening of the synagogue was so offensive and provocative to many. Enjoy the read. 


Why protest building a synagogue




The Hurva synagogue was destroyed in the 1948 war by the Jordanian army.  Before 1948, synagogues were used by Zionist underground forces for illicit activities including hording weapons.*  But why is there a furor over building it again? First we must recognize that International law is rather clear that East Jerusalem is illegally occupied by Israel and per the Geneva conventions, and buildings or activities in the occupied areas are subject to those conventions.  Any transfer of population to the occupied areas including infrastructure for these individuals is considered proscribed settlement activity contrary to both the letter and the spirit of the law. 

Second, Israel News reported that: "According to a centuries-old rabbinical prophecy that appears to be coming true, on March 16, 2010, Israel will begin construction of the Third Temple in Jerusalem.  During the 18th century, the Vilna Gaon, a respected rabbinical authority, prophesied that the Hurva Synagogue in Jerusalem, which was built during his day, would be destroyed and rebuilt twice, and that when the Hurva was completed for the third time, construction on the Third Temple would begin" http://www.israeltoday.co.il/default.aspx?tabid=178&nid=20063 Many Israelis believe this and there is a proliferation of designs, ceremonies and other events to launch this coming age of building a third temple. There are Muslim religious sites there: the first Qibla or direction of prayer for Islam and the third holiest site are the Haram Al-Sharif on this site.  There are Israeli digs underneath that threaten the site already and this only added fuel to the fire.

Third, Palestinians, Arabs, Muslims, and much of humanity, wonder why is it that such a synagogue is reconstructed but none of 1200 mosques and nearly 200 churches destroyed by Israel over the past 6 decades not allowed to be reconstructed? For me personally and for mostPalestinains, we know the history shows Jews, Christians, and Muslims living peacefully together for 1400 years under Islamic rule (with very few exceptions).  We know that it is possible to simply have a Jewish area, a Christian area, a Muslim area or even mixed areas.  We know it is possible even to intermarry, have friendships, etc.  But Zionism had a different idea and it did not revolve on coexisting but on ethnic cleansing and destruction of others.  How else can we explain the destruction of 530 villages and towns? How can we explain the rapid growth of colonial settlements on Palestinian land or even inside Palestinian homes? There is surely enough space here for all. Why are Palestinians denied the right to go to school just this week (see story and picture where they even held school at the checkpoint, http://www.maannews.net/eng/ViewDetails.aspx?ID=269548). Why not simply live and let live.  The density of population inside the Green line is now nearly 1/8th that of areas of the West Bank and Gaza that are designated reservations/ghettos for the native Palestinians. If Jews want to live in the old Jewish quarter of East Jerusalem and rebuild the synagogue there, why not allow the Palestinians to return to the old neighborhoods in West Jerusalem and rebuild the many churches and mosques there?

AIPAC issued a statement supporting Vice President Biden who claimed that there is no space between the US and Israel.  In other words, the US and Israeli interests and policies are/must be one and the same including on starvation, oppression, colonization etc.  (and oh yes, we have to always put Iran first now that we finished off Iraq for the sake of Israel). US General David Petreausdisagrees:

"Insufficient progress toward a comprehensive Middle East peace. The enduring hostilities between Israel and some of its neighbors present distinct challenges to our ability to advance our interests in the AOR. Israeli-Palestinian tensions often flare into violence and large-scale armed confrontations. The conflict foments anti-American sentiment, due to a perception of U.S. favoritism for Israel. Arab anger over the Palestinian question limits the strength and depth of U.S. partnerships with governments and peoples in the AOR and weakens the legitimacy of moderate regimes in the Arab world. Meanwhile, al-Qaeda and other militant groups exploit that anger to mobilize support. The conflict also gives Iran influence in the Arab world through its clients, Lebanese Hizballah and Hamas."

I would go much further and say the US interests and treasury have already been crippled by thesubserviant relationship to Israeli lobbies.  If the lobby finally succeeds in deepening the conflict with Iran, it will not be Iran that loses, but US and Israel will suffer a horrible blow.  The US economy would go into a tail spin and the value of the $3 billion dollars in US military aid to Israel will be reduced even further as the US dollar accelerates its decline.

ACTION: AIPAC and Christian Zionists are mobilizing thousands to write the congress and white house to keep funding and supporting Israel in its policies of colonial settlement expansion.  We can do no less write to the white house via http://www.whitehouse.gov/contact/ and to congress viahttp://house.gov/


Mazin Qumsiyeh, PhD
Popular Committee to to Resist the Wall and Settlements-Beit Sahour
A Bedouin in Cyberspace, a villager at home

__._,_.___

Friday, March 19, 2010

Friday prayer, Tear gas and Rocks

Friday morning I woke up unsure of the day's plan, still distraught from the week, still uncertain about how to perceive what's going on around me.  It was a mental tug of war trying to decide if I should go to Jerusalem, the epicenter of where things have been really going wrong, with my roommate for the day or not.  I finally decided to go for it, because the alternative would have been to just sit in my room to brew over things, ask and ask questions that had no answers.

My roommate, another friend from Nablus and I caught the 9 o'clock bus  from the Ramallah bus station to head towards Jerusalem.  The checkpoints supposedly earlier in the morning are not 'that bad' and as an international we had an alternative option of taking an alternative bus that goes around the checkpoint and not actually through  it.  This privilege is given to those with Israeli ID's and to those with international passports.

Qalandia checkpoint was eerily quiet in the morning, however, the remnants of the week long clashes were more than visible.  Mounds of displaced dirt, evident of where the soldiers had chased down protesters, soot on the streets, evident of fires, and burning tires from earlier in the week.

This was my first time in the Old City of Jerusalem.  Gated on all sides by ancient high walls, like a monstrous fort in the middle of a spacious western bustling city, the old city is like an intense mixture of the world's oldest structures, most sacred sites, meeting at the same spot.  The proximity of things, how incredibly close together  everything actually was, was something that I was completely unaware of and not only baffled by but completely perplexed by.   I felt frozen.  Standing in one spot, in front of me was the Dome of the Rock, the oldest Islamic building in the world, right in front of it was Al-Aqsa Mosque, the third holiest site in Islam, and in between was the Wailing Wall, the holiest of sites for Jews, and behind me was the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, a spot venerated by Christians as the spot where Jesus Christ was crucified.

How about all that for a nice Friday morning?  I couldn't take enough deep breaths to take it all in.

Around 11:30 we walked around the winding streets, covered with shops, weaving in and out of the Muslim, Jewish and the Armenian Quarter (all of which are so close they might as well be rooms in a big house) and the crowd kept on getting bigger and bigger.  Why? Like I said this was the epicenter of where things are really going wrong.  Last Friday, Israeli soldiers had prohibited Muslim men under the age of 50 to even enter the Old City, let alone pray the Jumaa prayer at the Al-Aqsa Mosque, and this week they had done the same thing. The city streets were littered with soldiers.  As prayer time crept up, so did the tension.  Standing on the entrance to the Al-Aqsa Mosque, we saw the soldiers blocking and monitoring who is going in, turning away those who were under 50, and arguing over who actually looked 50 or not.

Outside of the old city, soldiers with masks, grenades, guns, tear gas stood around hundreds of Muslim men who stood on the streets to make their call to prayer.  They pulled out their prayer rugs (laying them out horizontally so that more than one could pray on one), or grabbed  pieces of cardboard from the shops and bazaars behind them to serve as prayer rugs for their obligatory weekly prayer, as soldiers stood firmly with their M16 rifles watching them intently.  Photographers and journalists hovered around snapping away pictures from different angles of this event.  You probably won't see this on any American mainstream news.  The Israeli soldiers were also filming internationals who were watching, because they have a tendency to record those who shouldn't be seeing the 'wrong' things, they film internationals who attend protests so that at immigration they can be turned away.

It was heartbreaking to stand there and watch.  I kept on wondering what went through the soldiers' minds, what were they thinking, what were they defending, and if any part of them felt a glitch in their hearts for standing in the way of those who wanted to pray at their place of worship with guns and tear gas.

I made my way home a couple of hours after that, after walking around the city for a bit more.  When I got to the Arab Bus Station to catch my bus number 18 to get back to Ramallah, the bus driver told me that he would only drive to the border.  Normally, that bus goes straight through and drops everyone off at the center of town in Ramallah.  I was too tiered from the day but aware enough to realize ok that must mean that Qalandia has been closed off, and there's probably problems at the checkpoint.  About half an hour of driving, and seeing some protests on the way (protests about the new settlements that are being built), the bus stopped in front of Qalandia and everyone walked across the checkpoint, and on the other side I found a bus driver who asked me if I was trying to get to Ramallah.  Once inside, a friendly man told me that yes I was on the right bus and this one would drop me  off where I needed to go.

Again Qalandia was eerily quiet.  However, as soon as it started driving off, I could see a crowd of men slowly emerging closer.  it was funny because it was the typical, stereotypical scene that I've seen in news clips, young men with Keffiyahs wrapped all around their faces.

Suddenly there was a loud "POP! POP! POP!" and white smoke, I realized that it was a soldier shooting tear gas at the Palestinian boys and then a loud CLANK that made me jump out of my seat.  It was a rock that was hurled at the bus.

I couldn't have been happier to walk back home when the bus dropped me off.  It felt good to walk the same street that I took to and from school every day and turn the corner to walk in to the apartment thats been mine for the last two and a half months, it felt really nice after an emotionally draining day to feel like I got home safe and sound.

...with more questions on my mind, then I had woken up with in the morning.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ag1mArePD-M

Sunday, March 14, 2010

religion - part II

I was asked to substitute a 5th grade religion class one day as I sat down for my break.  They needed a teacher to cover the class and sitting in the teacher's room, I suddenly was the most suitable person to go cover.  "what do i teach them??" I asked, and the response I got was "I don't know, you're Muslim"
So I headed down and the entire classroom was a hectic chaos and they all seemed to quiet down for a bit wondering what I was doing there when I walked in.  I started the class slowly, first asking them what they were learning, and as I was asking them I was stopped by a student who suddenly shouted out "Are you Muslim or Christian??" and when I told them I was Muslim, I kid you not, there were gasps. and then a brief silence, and THEN students shouting out random things like "SAY SURAH FATIHA!!"  or "do you hate Israel??" and then transitioning into a melody of "say Surah Fatiha, say Surah Fatiha, say Surah Fatiha" or they'd point to their books, and ask "can you read this?? READ THIS!"

The sound of the bell ringing to mark the end of that class period was magic and bliss to my ears.  I came out, again appalled at how even at that age, there is a NEED for everyone to know which box every individual around them belongs to, a religious box is absolutely necessary. And I clearly do not fit into that box.

The most intense and emotional of these experiences actually happened less than 48 hours ago.  I'm still shaken by it.  Fadi's death has naturally made me think about faith, my relationship with God, and the fragility and value of life.  My mind was flooded with these thoughts and going to the service at the Church to see Fadi's mom and pay our respects to her and Fadi, I couldn't control my tears (even though I'm not a person to really cry, it's almost unheard of to have seen me cry if you don't belong to my immediate family).  We were greeted by Fadi's uncles on our way in and on our way out they were the ones showing us out.

Small conversation with them turned into something else.  One of Fadi's uncles started on a tangent of how astonishing it is if you really dig up the history of Islam and Muslims, and he kept on repeating "you will be astonished as to what you find.  you will be astonished".  Still wiping away tears, I was intrigued and puzzled as to where in the world this was going.  his tone turned more and more sour and he made the remark "Muslims claim that they worship 1 god.  But that is not true.  They worship 2 gods".  23 years of being Muslim, this was flashing news to me, so I asked him "which 2 gods do they worship?"  He looked at me and he said "They worship "Allah" and they worship the man Mohammad".  I hadn't said anything to his strange, crude, and disrespectful remarks, but to that statement I couldn't keep quiet.  Being inside of a church, at a service for someone that had passed away, I wasn't in the emotional state to even have the energy to feel outraged.  I simply told him "That's not true, Mohammad is a Prophet, not a god'. he looked at me for a brief second puzzled by why I would say that, and Maggie intervened to say "She's Muslim".  and there it was.  Both of the uncles who were there subtly making remarks about how stupid Islam was, immediately ganged up on me.  For a brief period of time both of them were asking awful things simultaneously, one asking "Who WAS Mohammed? why do you love him? Why is a he prophet?" and the other one asking "Why do you call him Mohammed? do you know what that means? that means the most praised, why do you praise Mohammed? why is HE the most praised and not Lord?"

I was in shock.  I just could not believe it.  But it didn't stop, they kept on going and going, saying awful things, each of which felt like a stab at the heart.  "Why do you read the Quran in Arabic? Do you understand Arabic?" to "do you know that Arabic translated into anything else doesnt mean the same thing anymore? Do you know that 90 percent of everything written in the Quran was stolen from us and the book of the Jews?"

there were many things that I could have said (for instance asking about the authenticity of the Bible, or asking the simple question of if the title of "most praised" bothers him, how does believing that God had a "son" not bother him), but all i could think was "I am here for your dead nephew, is this really the right time and place to be telling me how awful you think my religion is"
The cherry on top, was one of the uncles looking me in the eye to tell me "if you really want to know the truth, you must know Jesus Christ"
Being mindful that this was a service, that i was in a church, and that I couldnt take them anymore AND knowing that they wouldn't stop, I literally (and it was probably rude) walked away from them saying "I am here for your nephew Fadi, and I really need to go".

Suddenly there was an onpour of tears that came gushing out feeling so stripped and isolated from any spiritual comfort.  M needed to go inside the bigger church and I followed her inside, now crying inside of the church.  On our way out, Fadi's uncle was driving out.  He reversed his car seeing me, rolled down his window, and apologized.  I told him that it was fine, and that he was forgiven.  My roommate, being in such an awfully sticky position, replied, "well at least he apologized".
at least he apologized?? no he probably apologized because he's sorry that I haven't been saved by Jesus Christ.

I am just utterly shocked that truly, truly  people are blind and incapable of seeing each other as human beings sometimes.  I know that Fadi's uncles are loonies and nutcases, just like the thousands of crazy loonies and nutcases that exist in Islam or any other religion.  I don't see this encounter as something I would hold against Christianity, it would be foolish and dumb of me to think that way.  And I am not naive enough to think that that kind of insensitivity, hatred, and blindness doesnt exist  in the minds of people of my own faith.  What disturbs me most is to really see, feel and face the extent of hatred that exists, solely religious hatred.

When I walk in Jerusalem, and I see orthodox Jewish men and women dressed head to toe, fully garbed, I think to myself, how are you ANY different from really conservative Muslims? Seriously, you're just wearing a different style of clothes.  But the mental cage of thinking that you are the rightly chosen rightly guided all else are hell bound, is exactly the same. Seriously, crazy religious people, they just have different religions, but they are all the same people, almost like a reflection of each other.

Nothing like a nutcase to get you thinking.

The following images is to make you laugh if you think it's as funny as I think it is.  People are really silly if they see more differences than similarities.  These slight, sliiiiiiight differences somehow make it absolutely ok to hate one another, and fight like animals, killing each other over stupid things.  Honestly sometimes I wonder, as humans we pride ourselves in having the size of the brain that we have, our mind, and our conscience, and that we are above primitive animals.
Yet, if you think about it, there's no breed of primitive animals that brutally kill their own kind, their own species, unless needed for absolute survival.  But we humans, albeit having a conscience not only participate in brutality that animals would never think of doing to their own species, but more often than not we sit silently to condone it.

Here's the kick...this violence is at its worst with very little hope for ever attaining co-existence and peace in a piece of land called the "Holy Land"


                                    display 1.1 : muslim woman wearing a headscarf

         
                                     display 1.2 : a jewish woman wearing a headscarf

Display 2.1 : Orthodox Jewish men



Display 2.2 : Muslim Man



Display "important to notice".1 - Christian child praying


Display "important to notice".2 - muslim children praying

Display "important to notice".3  : jewish child praying

It's not that I think about only these 3 religions at conflict and that I feel only these 3 are the most important.  But in the context of where I am right now and what I'm seeing, these 3 are at it (although the Christians are more neutral than anything else, comparatively, in the whole scheme of things here)



religion - part I

when i was preparing to come to palestine, i sought out advice from friends and friends of friends who had been here before to get as precise of a picture as possible in terms of what i should anticipate when i'm questioned by the IDF at the border.  they all unanimously told me that telling them that i was Muslim would be a bad idea.  especially since my passport clearly says that I'm from Bangladesh.  given the circumstances, i needed to have a story, and being Muslim, even having heard of a Palestine, being socially aware in any way, being nothing but an Israeli loving dumb American tourist couldn't be a part of it.  I was even told to not bring a copy of the Quran, nor a prayer rug or any other symbolic item.

Naturally, I had to contemplate about this, a lot.  Practicality versus morality.  To say the least the mental tug of war was extremely difficult for me.

I made up my mind.  I needed to get into Palestine.  There couldn't be anything more pointless than telling IDF the truth, I'd get sent back to the US, back to square 1, and what good would that do? I wouldn't be able to do anything.  I wanted to be in Palestine, I wanted to work here, I wanted to be socially active for something that I believed in, and I did not want to let it slip from my hands because of political bullshit.  I prayed a lot, and I hope that at the end of the day God forgives me for the lies, and sees my intention inshAllah.

So it began.  I was Christian, as were my parents, I was going to Israel, I didn't even know what the Palestinian territories were and I loved Israel.  Did I mention that I love Israel? Because I really love Israel.

After 3 and a half hours of waiting, being interrogated, sitting around, being interrogated again, waiting, we got in.  Thankfully, they didn't check my suitcase that did have my prayer rug and my copy of the Qur'an in it.

Working in a Catholic school, my company has been predominantly Christian, although there are many Muslim teachers and Muslim students.  It's very hard to tell who's who though.  The way that others found out that I actually wasn't Christian, was when they'd invite me over for dinner and wine, and I'd have to reply with "sure! I'd love to come over.  but I don't drink wine".  They'd look at me in surprise and ask "why not???"  and I'd have to say with a chuckle "Because I'm Muslim."      ... "oh!":: awkward transition:: "well we'll have Sprite instead!"

As wonderful as it's been to be embraced without any judgement (though I'm definitely considered Bangladeshi at school and not American because I'm brown, and Maggie is definitely the American teacher) for the past couple of months I've felt like an outsider in my community and stuck in a strange limbo of neither belonging here nor there.  I'm so used to having a Muslim community around me that is receptive, and I'm so used to be able to go to the Mosque to pray that suddenly being stripped from that IN a Muslim country has caused mental discomfort and strife.

Earlier this year, before the Israeli govt took the Palestinian side of the Ibrahimi mosque, M and I had gone to Hebron to see it.  At the checkpoint, we were let through under the pretext of both of us being Christian.  When I went inside the mosque, a friendly looking man approached us offering to show us around, anticipating that I was Muslim, and when I told him that I wasn't (not wanting to change the story from what I told the guards), he basically treated us like shit the entire time we were there.  It was jarring for him to treat us the way he did thinking that I was something that I was not, and it was jarring to think that his treatment would be so different had he known that I was really Muslim.

Are people really incapable of seeing each other as human beings?