So I headed down and the entire classroom was a hectic chaos and they all seemed to quiet down for a bit wondering what I was doing there when I walked in. I started the class slowly, first asking them what they were learning, and as I was asking them I was stopped by a student who suddenly shouted out "Are you Muslim or Christian??" and when I told them I was Muslim, I kid you not, there were gasps. and then a brief silence, and THEN students shouting out random things like "SAY SURAH FATIHA!!" or "do you hate Israel??" and then transitioning into a melody of "say Surah Fatiha, say Surah Fatiha, say Surah Fatiha" or they'd point to their books, and ask "can you read this?? READ THIS!"
The sound of the bell ringing to mark the end of that class period was magic and bliss to my ears. I came out, again appalled at how even at that age, there is a NEED for everyone to know which box every individual around them belongs to, a religious box is absolutely necessary. And I clearly do not fit into that box.
The most intense and emotional of these experiences actually happened less than 48 hours ago. I'm still shaken by it. Fadi's death has naturally made me think about faith, my relationship with God, and the fragility and value of life. My mind was flooded with these thoughts and going to the service at the Church to see Fadi's mom and pay our respects to her and Fadi, I couldn't control my tears (even though I'm not a person to really cry, it's almost unheard of to have seen me cry if you don't belong to my immediate family). We were greeted by Fadi's uncles on our way in and on our way out they were the ones showing us out.
Small conversation with them turned into something else. One of Fadi's uncles started on a tangent of how astonishing it is if you really dig up the history of Islam and Muslims, and he kept on repeating "you will be astonished as to what you find. you will be astonished". Still wiping away tears, I was intrigued and puzzled as to where in the world this was going. his tone turned more and more sour and he made the remark "Muslims claim that they worship 1 god. But that is not true. They worship 2 gods". 23 years of being Muslim, this was flashing news to me, so I asked him "which 2 gods do they worship?" He looked at me and he said "They worship "Allah" and they worship the man Mohammad". I hadn't said anything to his strange, crude, and disrespectful remarks, but to that statement I couldn't keep quiet. Being inside of a church, at a service for someone that had passed away, I wasn't in the emotional state to even have the energy to feel outraged. I simply told him "That's not true, Mohammad is a Prophet, not a god'. he looked at me for a brief second puzzled by why I would say that, and Maggie intervened to say "She's Muslim". and there it was. Both of the uncles who were there subtly making remarks about how stupid Islam was, immediately ganged up on me. For a brief period of time both of them were asking awful things simultaneously, one asking "Who WAS Mohammed? why do you love him? Why is a he prophet?" and the other one asking "Why do you call him Mohammed? do you know what that means? that means the most praised, why do you praise Mohammed? why is HE the most praised and not Lord?"
I was in shock. I just could not believe it. But it didn't stop, they kept on going and going, saying awful things, each of which felt like a stab at the heart. "Why do you read the Quran in Arabic? Do you understand Arabic?" to "do you know that Arabic translated into anything else doesnt mean the same thing anymore? Do you know that 90 percent of everything written in the Quran was stolen from us and the book of the Jews?"
there were many things that I could have said (for instance asking about the authenticity of the Bible, or asking the simple question of if the title of "most praised" bothers him, how does believing that God had a "son" not bother him), but all i could think was "I am here for your dead nephew, is this really the right time and place to be telling me how awful you think my religion is"
The cherry on top, was one of the uncles looking me in the eye to tell me "if you really want to know the truth, you must know Jesus Christ"
Being mindful that this was a service, that i was in a church, and that I couldnt take them anymore AND knowing that they wouldn't stop, I literally (and it was probably rude) walked away from them saying "I am here for your nephew Fadi, and I really need to go".
Suddenly there was an onpour of tears that came gushing out feeling so stripped and isolated from any spiritual comfort. M needed to go inside the bigger church and I followed her inside, now crying inside of the church. On our way out, Fadi's uncle was driving out. He reversed his car seeing me, rolled down his window, and apologized. I told him that it was fine, and that he was forgiven. My roommate, being in such an awfully sticky position, replied, "well at least he apologized".
at least he apologized?? no he probably apologized because he's sorry that I haven't been saved by Jesus Christ.
I am just utterly shocked that truly, truly people are blind and incapable of seeing each other as human beings sometimes. I know that Fadi's uncles are loonies and nutcases, just like the thousands of crazy loonies and nutcases that exist in Islam or any other religion. I don't see this encounter as something I would hold against Christianity, it would be foolish and dumb of me to think that way. And I am not naive enough to think that that kind of insensitivity, hatred, and blindness doesnt exist in the minds of people of my own faith. What disturbs me most is to really see, feel and face the extent of hatred that exists, solely religious hatred.
When I walk in Jerusalem, and I see orthodox Jewish men and women dressed head to toe, fully garbed, I think to myself, how are you ANY different from really conservative Muslims? Seriously, you're just wearing a different style of clothes. But the mental cage of thinking that you are the rightly chosen rightly guided all else are hell bound, is exactly the same. Seriously, crazy religious people, they just have different religions, but they are all the same people, almost like a reflection of each other.
Nothing like a nutcase to get you thinking.
The following images is to make you laugh if you think it's as funny as I think it is. People are really silly if they see more differences than similarities. These slight, sliiiiiiight differences somehow make it absolutely ok to hate one another, and fight like animals, killing each other over stupid things. Honestly sometimes I wonder, as humans we pride ourselves in having the size of the brain that we have, our mind, and our conscience, and that we are above primitive animals.
Yet, if you think about it, there's no breed of primitive animals that brutally kill their own kind, their own species, unless needed for absolute survival. But we humans, albeit having a conscience not only participate in brutality that animals would never think of doing to their own species, but more often than not we sit silently to condone it.
Here's the kick...this violence is at its worst with very little hope for ever attaining co-existence and peace in a piece of land called the "Holy Land"
display 1.1 : muslim woman wearing a headscarf
display 1.2 : a jewish woman wearing a headscarf
Display 2.1 : Orthodox Jewish men
Display 2.2 : Muslim Man
Display "important to notice".1 - Christian child praying
Display "important to notice".2 - muslim children praying
Display "important to notice".3 : jewish child praying
It's not that I think about only these 3 religions at conflict and that I feel only these 3 are the most important. But in the context of where I am right now and what I'm seeing, these 3 are at it (although the Christians are more neutral than anything else, comparatively, in the whole scheme of things here)
this is intense
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your feelings with us. I agree with you: we must look 'others' with the eyes and feeling of "humanity" - NOT by the color, age, sex, race, nationality, ethnicity or RELEGION.
ReplyDeleteAll newborn universally acquire the 'name and religious (faith) of his parents' as inharent IDENITITY of his ancestors with no exception. When that child gorws up he learns everything from his surroundings where he is born. Almost all the time he is fed by the religious teaching and glories (many of them are 'myth and blunt lies' of generations passing as perceive truth for thousands of years - one such Myth/lies is: Jews , Christian and Muslims lived in Middle East 'peacefully' for 1400 years) of his ancestors and make him believe that his religion(faith) is 'the best and Humen' among all other faith/religions on Earth.
At one point when he becomes older, depending upon the intensity of his faith, he is partially or completely blind and incapable of thinking and feeling rationally the views and faith of others. To overcome this incapacity one must read the history from all different views and angles and think rationally without any prejudice.
Overcoming one's own prejudiice is an extremely difficult task - it needs constant practice of learning and rational thinking with the mind of FLEXIBILITY of changing his past views when evidences are overwhelming and contrary. When one can acquire this kind of mindset -only then he can claim as Rational and Free thinker.
You wrote, "One of Fadi's uncles -- how astonishing -- really dig up the history of Islam and Muslims - on repeating -- be astonished -- you find-remark --claim --they worship 1 god. --worship 2 gods". --worship "Allah" and they worship the man Mohammad --". It appears to me that Fadi's uncle is very learned man and knows 'exactly' what he is talking about. Muslims are not only worship 2 gods, they worship Mohammad more than their 'Allah'. It is evidenced by the fact that in Muslim world (in fact in whole world) it is safer to criticize 'Allah' rather than Mohammad - if one carries a different view between those gods contrary to the views of Muslims.
Once you learn the "History of Islam -by Muslim scholars/Historian"(you do not have to believe any Non-Muslim historian if you choose not to) with the mind of a FREE THINKER AND A RATIONAL HUMAN you have no difficulty understanding what a "surprise waiting for you - what Fadi's uncle was appropraitely referring you 'astonishing if you really dig up --'. You were surprised and upset by his comment - that only proves that you are not familiar with the history of Islam and as such holding the Myth carries by billions of Muslim worldwide.
You also said, Fadi's uncle was telling "Who WAS Mohammed? why do you love him? Why is a he prophet?" and the other one asking "Why do you call him Mohammed? do you know what that means? that means the most praised, why do you praise Mohammed? why is HE the most praised and not Lord?". It is obvious that you are surprised by this comment too. I am sure you will understand the real meaning of 'why he said so' if you dig the Biography of Mohammad -all by renound Muslim author/scholars and historians. Again, I am assuring you, you do not have to rely on any Non-Muslim author/ scholars and historians if you choose not to.
You are also surprised by the statement of fadi's uncle, " --90 percent of everything written in the Quran was stolen from us and the book of the Jews?". It is not the ninety percent - almost 100% of Islam's teaching and rituals are from other contemporary faiths of of Arabian Pennisula of that time are incorporated in Islam.
I appreciate your eagerness of looking the world with the eyes of 'Humanity'. That can never be achieved with perfection if you ever consider yourself in any other group (mentioned above) except HUMAN.
Abbu
Fahmida,
ReplyDeleteThis and the last post are very very well written and thought out. Your strength is dealing with this conflict and your ability to withstand this is admirable. I wish we could wrap our minds around this hatred, but it's hard for me to get past the astonishment of how much hatred there actually is.